July 13, 2006 08:30 PM by Joe Blackmon
The first Big Brother All Stars eviction episode starts off with Danielle and Alison lobbying the other houseguests for their votes to remain in the house. Danielle lobbies Chicken George, while Alison lobbies Nakomis. Mike Boogie says if Alison stays then it will be catfight central between here and Janelle. Danielle breaks down into tears about the bad rap she got after Big Brother season three.
Julie Chen chats with the houseguests and shows footage of Chicken George snoring. Julie also points out to viewers that at one time Jase Wirey was one of the most hated houseguests in Big Brother 5, but in All Stars he is popular both inside and outside the house. Jase talks about how he is a more refined player this season and says having a committed relationship has calmed him down.
Julie Chen gives Danielle and Alison a chance to address the houseguests. Danielle says she’s honored to be here with the All Stars and respects and loves everyone. Alison says she’s also honored, especially to be sitting next to Danielle who she considers one of the best players in Big Brother history. By a vote of 8 to 2, Alison is evicted from the Big Brother house. Diane Henry and Nakomis cast the two lone votes to evict Danielle.
When Julie Chen questions Alison on why she was evicted so early, Alison says that she lost her evil touch that she had in Big Brother 4. Julie Chen asks why she didn’t flirt with all the guys like last time, and Alison says because she’s found the one. Julie Chen reads some of Alison’s comments about Janelle, but Alison says she’s a great person and a great competitor and apologizes.
The head of household competition is called “Alison Rules” and involves answering true of false as to how Alison answered a series of questions. When Julie asks question three “True or false, prior to entering the Big Brother All Stars house, Alison believed her toughest competition was Erika,” Kaysar and Nakomis are the only two to correctly answer the question as true.
For question five, Julie asks “True of false, Alison believes the All Star most likely to seek revenge by using someone’s toothbrush to clean the toilet is Will.” Kaysar answers false, while Nakomis answers true. Julie then announces that Alison’s answer was false, but in a bewildering moment congratulates Nakomis for winning head of household. As Nakomis looks on in confusion over hearing herself announced as the winner when she answered the question incorrectly, Julie says “Oh, I am so sorry, it is Kaysar, my mistake. Sorry Nakomis. Kaysar, you are the new head of household.”