« | Home | »

Big Brother Spoiler, All Stars Doll Fight

August 20, 2006 11:11 PM by Joe Blackmon

Is Big Brother All Stars rigged to insure that Janelle Pierzina wins?  Or is James Rhine just a big whiner?  These are the questions that are buzzing among Big Brother fans after another controversial Big Brother competition.  Earlier this season, some obvious technical malfunctions resulted in a do over for the HOH competition.  The redo wound up benefiting Janelle who went from likely nomination to being head of household.  Now, another controversy is playing out on the Big Brother live feeds (stop reading now if you don’t want to know what happened).   

The latest Big Brother controversy stems from a fight over a doll in a power of veto competition.  As revealed on the Big Brother Sunday episode, Mike Boogie is the head of household.  On the live feeds, Mike Boogie has nominated Janelle and James for eviction.  In the power of veto competition, houseguests were asked a series of questions and then had to race to grab a doll that looked like the houseguest that was the correct answer to the question. 

According to James, Janelle had grabbed a Howie doll that was the incorrect answer, and he had grabbed a Marcellas doll that was the correct answer.  When Janelle realized that she had the incorrect doll, James claims she yanked the Marcellas doll out of his hands and scratched him in the process.  On the live feeds, James is complaining about Janelle getting physical and taking away a doll that was in his possession.   

On the other hand, Janelle claims that her and James were struggling over the Howie doll, when she realized that Marcellas was the correct answer.  She says she let James have the Howie doll and grabbed the Marcellas doll instead. 

So who is telling the truth?  With all the cameras in the Big Brother house, it would seem like the simple answer would be to review the tapes.  However, according to statements made by James, Big Brother somehow doesn’t have footage at the right angle to actually discern what happened.  Please discuss in the comments section below if you think there should be a redo of the power of veto competition or not. 

Reality TV Magazine is your source for Big Brother All Stars news.  For other great Big Brother All Stars news, please also check out SirLinksALot: Big Brother All Stars. 

Topics: Big Brother |

« | Home | »

recommended for you


54 Responses to “Big Brother Spoiler, All Stars Doll Fight”

  1. Anonymous Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 12:05 am

    Maybe if Janelle uses the power of veto and Boogie has to put someone else up, he will use his secret power to change the nominations last minute before the final vote and put Janelle back on the block. He would probably have the votes to evict her. So, it may not matter anyway.

  2. Corran Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 1:04 am

    Um, no not really. Winners of POV are safe from eviction. Bye Bye Chicken or Erica! I sincerely hope they do a do-over. I believe James more than I believe Janelle, who at this point would do everything in her power to not be evicted, which is inevitable.

  3. Will Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 2:22 am

    That´s right. Mike cannot nominate the HOH nor the POV holder, so I guess Janelle is safe again. Although I believe she made a stupid decision when she did not nominate Will or Mike, I want her to win since she is the underdog.

  4. Forestpal Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 4:25 am

    Ilook at this episode as I would a loose basketball situation. Take the disputed Marcellas doll to the sideline, throw him onto the court, and who comes up with the doll gets to keep him. Then the lucky person who gets the doll simply dribbles him down court and tries to throw him through the hoop. If the doll goes into the hoop, give the player who threw him, two points.
    Do this only to keep the whiners busy, instead of having them run to the DR to complain about unfairness.
    This is Big Brother. Fairness? If they are going to base a decision on fairness, why don’t they test James and Janelle for steroids?
    Silly discussion. The game is not rigged — it’s flawed. What next? Check under Janelle’s fingernails for James’ DNA?
    Let the kids play. No blood, no foul.

  5. Kenneth Elliott Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 5:29 am

    Janelle an underdog…lmao. I hope she gets evicted, I’m tired of her winning. She has been doing nothing but playing for herself the whole time with no real regard for what was best for her alliance. I hope Chicken George or Danielle to win it. BRING BACK JASE!!!!

  6. Magiq Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 6:18 am

    It hasn’t been mentioned on tv yet but Mike lost his Coup D’etat power for telling Danielle and Will that he had it. He was supposed to keep it secret until the time he used it.

    With Janelle safe it’s time to rid the show of the other volatile player in the game, James.

    He has been zero fun to watch on this show and deserves to be stuck with Howie and Marcellus in sequester.

    It would be really cool if they got to see what he had to say about them before he arrived too. Then he’d be whining that nobody was talking to him.

    The best player in BB history should win this thing… GO WILL!

  7. carrie Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:03 am

    I do not think that it should be redone, and Janie would be safe anyone, because the new power excluded the hoh and the pov winner. But I also heard that boogie lost his power by telling dani about it.

  8. Mike C Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:20 am

    James whines about everything so its no surprise this “doll” competion has sparked yet another controverys. Janie should have plugged him with the doll and finally shut him up. He has been one long whine this season-what an earsoar!! Evict him now before its too late. Go Janie!

  9. Jacqui Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:30 am

    I don’t think it should be re-done. James deserves what he got..God doesn’t like ugly. He’s a backstabbing no good, why should he think that anyone in or out of the house would sympathize with him. The thing I don’t understand is why people are complaining about S6 and Janelle’s winning streak. Everyone in the house could have gottren together and voted them out, instead of saying they had an unfair advantage. It would have been the whole house against 4 people. S6 won all those HOH fair and square. As for Janelle she is always studying when all the other are doing is scheming and backstabbing her. No wonder she is so good at this game. If they used the same energy they wasted on Janelle to really play the game, then the others would do better. Kudo’s to Will for helping Janelle to clean the pie of her face, while the other were hooping it up and celebrating her loss. She looked so all aone. No wonder America loves her. GO JANELLE

  10. JayC Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:55 am

    The comp’ should not be re-done, james is just whinning becuz he’s on the block and he doesn’t trust chilltown, and since people are always telling him he’s the veto king he’s just pissed off becuz janelle is proving him wrong and beating his ass in every thing, I SOOO GLAD FA DE HEFFER!!!

    Shout out to de caribbean

  11. Dianna Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:59 am

    Re-do the competition. Big Brother already screwed up once and are probably too embarrassed to do admit it again.

  12. Arabella Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 9:05 am

    How can we possibly comment on something we didn’t see?

    It sounds to me like big bad James got into a wrestling match with a girl and lost. Now he’s crying that she didn’t play fair. She snatched his dolly away.

    If he’s not winning, then the game must be rigged. How old is he? 10?

  13. Arabella Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 9:05 am

    How can we possibly comment on something we didn’t see?

    It sounds to me like big bad James got into a wrestling match with a girl and lost. Now he’s crying that she didn’t play fair. She snatched his dolly away.

    If he’s not winning, then the game must be rigged. How old is he? 10?

  14. Brent Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 9:07 am

    Boogie lost his coup power because he can’t over throw himself and this is the 3rd eviction anyways. He had 3 evictions to use it, it is that simple.

  15. Kerry Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 9:31 am

    Go Janie!! Bye whiner James…….I hope Howie goes hurricane on you in sequester :)

  16. BigFatDaddy Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 10:23 am

    I have thought the game was fixed from day one. In the “Dig your own Grave” competition. We never saw any indication of how it was played out. How the points really added up. Or could we see who ring in first. Wow Janelle won, surprise surprise. CBS wants drama and they think Janelle brings it

  17. alex(andra) Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 10:23 am

    i think this week will be the demise of james, which saddens me cause i was in his corner for some time now. boogie plans to put up george and assures him he’s safe, it will be a tie vote and boogie will break the tie by evicting james (not smart boogie, if you make it to final 2, you just lost another more vote, which makes it 3)he lied to marcy’s face, then howie, and now james. it is one thing to lie and backstab, but keep in mind that these are the people who will be picking the winner in the end. will was smart about it, his message to marci was smart, sounded sincere, and probably earned him a vote in the end if he’s up against boogie. howie too would vote for him because of that quarrel he had with boogie, and when boogie is the one who evicts james this week, u better believe he’s out 500 Gs. NOT SMART BOOGIE. i am still hoping james will pull this off. he has erika and dani, and if he can make a mends with jani, he will be here another week. GEORGE HAS TO GO he has lied too many times. though i was happy when howie was evicted, i cannot believe it was at the hands of george. howie was great to this man and george totally betrayed him. hopefully james can use this to his advantage, he can tell janelle that george is the reason why howie is gone and maybe she’ll vote to evict him. AND HOPEFULLY by now people see chilltown as a threat and finally take them out. i think jani has seen the light and knows what she has to do. stop trying to take the women out and take out the two people responsible for sending 2 of your alliance members home. i guess we’ll have to see how this week plays out and true colours will be exposed. this is where we’ll see who is playing with who. GO JAMES , dani, and erika!!!

  18. Courtney Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 10:42 am

    Janelle deserves to win and everyone knows it! They just redid a competition why would they do it again! they are making the new competitions to where no one can complain that it was unfair but james still complains! what a loser! I used to like him be4 he backstabbed S6 and thats not cool!

  19. Marc S., Charlotte NC Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 10:50 am

    Janelle screwed the entire show up for BB6 when she believed a word out of Will’s mouth. WIll and Boogie have controlled this entire house from week 5 and have not looked back since. Janelle let Kaser get screwed, last night she let Howie get screwed. She is the biggest idiot of the season. Chilltown even has James and Daniel in their pocket and James may be removed from that pocket and discarded this week. Chicken George was (until last night) the only player that Chilltown had not gotten to. But Mike put the fear of God in him and he caved in. Will and Boogie are going down the stretch and I think Will might give it to Boogie in the end. But he may cut those puppet string attached to Boogie and let him fall as well. Have to wait and see on that one. The only question is can Will EVER win any competition? Sorry BB6, you started out strong but Janelle let it all go wrong!

  20. Jessica Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 10:55 am

    James is a big fat baby. I can’t stand him or his smack talk about his so called friends. I hope after Howie and Janelle see this show they never speak to him again, and his poor girlfriend Sarah, being with such a miserable human being. Janelle is a great player and everyone just needs to get over it. Go Janie!!!!

  21. Steve Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 12:00 pm

    Janelle is a transexual! No wonder she got the doll away from James.
    Go Legion of Doom

  22. Fran Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 12:28 pm

    I hope in the end it will be between Will and Janelle. I always love Will as a player and respect Janelle for being just upfront. Too bad she had a bit of a feeling for Will and Boogie. This is a game and she should know that personal feelings for someone should not enter into it. I hope she has seen the light and win this thing. I also hoped that Howie straigthened out Marci in the house and tell him that everyone was after him, and Janelle is the only one who stuck with him till the end. I hope Janey wins.

  23. Kim Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 12:37 pm


  24. Santeemom Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 1:03 pm

    If you go back and review all the events that James has lost over his two seasons on BB (not the ones he “threw” of course) you will no doubt find that he claims they were either rigged or they were somehow unfair.
    James is a prime example of a poor sport.

  25. Mike C Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 1:49 pm

    i agree w/some of these postings. I think its odd Dr. Will has won no competions. We want to believe this is some kind of stategy11(everybody else does the dirty work!) but we cant be sure. He could just be inept!!All talk no real action. Lots like this.

    I dont think the show is “rigged”. James will complain about anything and everything!!
    But I still cant get over the HOH comp where Dani gave that outrageous answer about minutes HG’s on cold water!!! Here is an intelligent, great player and she cannot calculate simple minutes!!
    The quess was so, so far off!!
    What’s up w/that??In some crazy way is she emulating Dr. Wills game??Just asking.

    Would love to see Janie and Dr. Will final two. They are by far the two best players in BB History. Janie cannot be stopped and Dr. Will’s entertaining and brillant at lying,manipulation, other low-tricks of the trade.

    These two have earned the right for final two. But what if Chicken George makes it??We all lose!!1

  26. SweetGirl Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 2:52 pm

    I agree with Kenneth Elliot..bring back Jase..He was so cool.
    On the other hand i can’t wait to see who will make it to the final two. I wish its Will ( he is just so cool and smart even though he didn’t win any competitions) and Janelle. I didn’t like her in the beginning but now i am starting to like her. She is trying so hard to save herself each week.
    And for Howie, give me a break, the guy is just so annoying i didn’t like him at all.
    If it comes to Will or Boogie in the final two, Will will take the money. Will was smart about playing the game, he didn’t piss off anybody YET.
    It was funny when Howie said to Boogie ” Bros over hoes” not knowing that Boogie and Erica are in so called “showmance”. Haha….
    So wait did Boogie lose his power or not???

  27. Anonymous Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 4:42 pm

    Oh PLEEASE for the love of god, the show is not rigged. IF the show were rigged (espeically in Janey’s behalf) she would have won the coup, plus when she won the homecoming queen she was supposed to have an adavatage in H.O.H comp but she got nothing because she wasn’t able to compete in the comp; if it were rigged they would have allowed her to pass her power to a guest of her choice. It seems to me that people (AKA JAMES) only cry foul when Janey wins something. AS I recall James also cried and foul and had a tantrum when Chicken George won POV (It never aired on TV, but on the live feeds he had a major melt down.)
    The point is, the show is not rigged, a little ridculous maybe (Hence the little people pie throwing H.O.H comp and the lame america choice options so far) but it definitely isn’t rigged.

  28. Mike C Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 5:16 pm

    Spoiler Alert!!! Chicken George has just been nominated. This is anyone quess who goes-James or George. But James should as he has been a major jerk this season and would love to see him have a major meltdown ala’ Howie!!! Of course, he’ll dish Janie on the way out and Jury hourse but what can they do?? He played all the wrong cards this season-won One HOH and Veto compared to Janie’s Three HOH’s and 3 Vetos!! Wow, did he wuss out here!!

  29. margaret Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 7:56 pm

    Janelle has been fighting for her life inthe bb house since she came in.Everyone has been against her including James. How can you stick up for darnelle when she has been after her since day one. Janelle was nice enough to hug her after the first eviction but she still bad mouthed her. What I see is just plain jealousy.

  30. margaret Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 7:57 pm

    Janelle has been fighting for her life inthe bb house since she came in.Everyone has been against her including James. How can you stick up for darnelle when she has been after her since day one. Janelle was nice enough to hug her after the first eviction but she still bad mouthed her. What I see is just plain jealousy.

  31. Mike C Says:
    August 21st, 2006 at 8:21 pm

    I certainly am not a Dani fan. However, she is a great player. Obviously, all these people have been after Janie since Day 1. Janie has won more in her two seasons than any of these “scangers”. She is disliked for all kinds of petty, spiteful reasons. But she continues to win.
    She will really have to get HOH this week but we saw her do it last season and these cutthroaters are worse, savy players than the sloppy Nerd Herders.
    Final Two: Janie and Dr. Chill.
    They have earned it. Erika, Boogie, and Chicken George have not.

  32. Tami Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:15 am

    Poor James.
    The little GIRL took his dolly away. He is no Man. Cry james Cry.

    NO – To REDO the POV!!
    I say the decision stands!

    Boogie should be Bully.


  33. Marsha Jenkins Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:46 am

    Poor Poor James! Everyone always does him wrong! He has proved that he doesn’t know the meaning of allegience and will betray anyone to win! Now he has hooked up with people who will betray him as fast as he has betrayed season 6. Janelle is the best player ever and deserves to win. If big bad James can’t handle the heat he needs to stay out of the kitchen!

  34. Dallas Fan Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 10:33 am

    PLEASE EVICT JAMES! He is so lame!I will be delighted to see him go. I, too, would like to see Will and Janelle as the final two. Will is a good player and has planned all along to NOT win a competition. He sails safely under the radar that way. Janelle is my favorite because she gives it her all! I enjoyed hearing her Mom talk about her. James will NOT make a good jury member when he is evicted, he hates them all. Wish he had gone earlier.

  35. Rhonda Mac Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 2:17 pm

    I like Janelle and think that when people say that she is a back stabber they are very nieve to what the others are doing to play the game. She is great and does know how to play the game! James is a whiner and this was proven when he said he didn’t know what he was doing when he didn’t take Danielle out after promising he would to his #6 alliance. GO JANELLE GO! NO REDO!

  36. Rhonda Mac Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 2:21 pm

    Why didn’t Dr. Chill own up to asking Chicken to put him up on the block so Boogie didn’t go psycho – this makes me truly believe that Dr. Chill will screw Boogie at some point and take Janelle to the final two:)

  37. SweetGirl Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 3:44 pm

    I wish Dr.Will and Janelle go to final two. It would be very interesting to see who would win.
    And I honestly don’t care about REDO. As everyone can see Janelle keeps winning POV and HOH and its great.
    Wow James complaining..thats an old news..he IS always complaining about something…

  38. mandee Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 3:47 pm

    well, lets see here. janelle DID sell out her alliance, she has lost james (because he was the first to see where her loyalty stood) then kaysar, then howie. she put her faith in people who are responsible for their demises. and what does she plan to do next? boogie is in a tight spot right now. do you get rid of the chicken man who doesnt deserve the money, but would win it through pity if he were in the final 2, or do you get rid of james who would most likely not have the votes because he sold out his alliance(s) who are on the jury. the odds are better if he kept james. i like james, i think he’s the only one in that house who has not lost sight of the fact it is indeed just a game, and emotions should not get thrown into the mix. boogie should have been one of the many firsts to get evicted in that house. his strategy is degrading, and if he makes it to the final 2, there is no way in hell he would win the money. one, erika will not vote for him when she realizes he’s gunning for her, marci has never liked him and thus would not vote for him, howie, well, his eviction speaks for itself, he aint gettin a vote there, and regardless of who goes home this week, he’s not getting that forth vote because he told them both that they are safe. right now, will has the best chances of getting the votes if he’s in final two, and thats ONLY if he’s NOT sitting next to janelle in the end cause that would be a toss up, either one would have a good chance, and the way things are going, that maybe our final 2. i’m still pulling for erika, and dani, and james if he doesnt go this week. i guess we’ll wait and see.

  39. Mike C Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 5:35 pm

    There is no way Boogie should or would get the money. He is beyound annoying. Almost wish Howie would have shook him up before he left.
    And, sorry, I would rather see Cowboy get the money if he were in there house. Boogie’s head is larger than ???????

  40. Sharlene Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 5:58 pm

    Last week when James won the P.O.V. which resulted in Howie’s evition, he was happier then a pig in s***. This week he is just ashamed that “the veto king” has fallen. In other reality shows such as survivor, there are often physical battles during comp.’s but the contestants are true competitors because they don’t start whining about lawyers and contracts. Give me a break James…I also would like to say that I feel bad for Sarah ’cause she must be getting an earful from family and friends!!

  41. JJ Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:05 pm

    James is totally lame! We all saw it tonight, and he is full of it.

  42. Mike C Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:14 pm

    Awsome seeing Janie kick James-the Veto King-rear end tonight. Finally, this should be the end of the perpetually sad-eyed james. Enough!!
    Final three should be: Janie, Dr. Chill, and….Chicken George!!!

  43. Libby Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:16 pm

    James is a big whiner. BB showed the footage tonight – Janelle clearly grabbed the doll before James. She “kicked” him when she feel back into him. Get over it dude, as Will said “she whopped your *ss.”

  44. Anonymous Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 9:54 pm

    Who was put up when Janelle took herself off the block???

  45. Anonymous Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 10:13 pm

    janelle rocks – but her time is limited – clearly Will is the best manipulater in the game – what a mastermind – if the women where smarter ( this includes Marcellas – of coure) on this show – they should have teamed up and got all the guys out – that’s what I’m talking about

  46. Donna McCoy Says:
    August 22nd, 2006 at 10:27 pm

    James is beneath contempt. The difference between him and someone like Will is that James is coming from a mean place, and I don’t think you have to dig too deep to find it. I was starting to feel for him in the beginning, but then he turned into the same immature, hateful, selfish person as last season. He’s so jealous of anyone who does better than he, and his girlfriend must just be in total denial. The odds have been against Janelle from day one, and I admire her more than ever after seeing the others all leave her standing alone after Howie left. She always seems to muster up more determination when things go against her. I’d love to see her win, but I’m afraid all those self-righteous, judgemental females will deny her the money. I wouldn’t be surprised to see Janelle get some kind of showbiz offer out of this, something that will prove far more valuable than winning the game. How about the Janelle And Marcellus Show?

  47. Buddy Says:
    August 23rd, 2006 at 8:32 am

    I watched the show last night and it looked like James had the Marcellas Doll and it was ripped out of his handby Janelle. If you remember the Barry Bonds Home Run ball that was grabbed by a fan from the one who had initially caught it. The courts rulled that the ball belonged to the initial holder. It looks like the show wants to keep Janelle on for ratings. Competitions should have clear winners. I am disappointed in who is getting most of the air time. It looks like the Will and Janelle show.

  48. susan Says:
    August 23rd, 2006 at 10:27 am

    I don’t know who it will come down to – but I believe Will and Janelle are the best players. Will carefully manipulates the players without them realizing it – and he is so funny! Janelle is strong, very smart and pays close attention to detail because she knows it will count in certain competitions. They are both great but if it came down to just the 2 of them I don’t think anyone would give Will the money again. He won the money already – but he has won our hearts. I liked Erika for a long time and was excited to have her in All Stars but she is the female version of James. She has a deal with just about everyone in the house and she’s not very nice.
    Boogie is mean – I can’t stand the way he put it to George in front of everyone. But it worked. I don’t like the way he was nasty to Howie on the way out. Howie was getting annoying – he took the playing dumb and sexist thing too far. (I don’t think he was that dumb – CBS let us see the smart Howie on occasion) It totally worked against him. I think George and Dani are non-descript and need to go. Ok that’s my input.

  49. Frankie D Says:
    August 23rd, 2006 at 2:51 pm

    Why would they do the POV competition over? Did Janelle break any rules??

  50. 2 Big 4 Britches Says:
    August 23rd, 2006 at 10:52 pm

    Chill Town messed up royally this week. By throwing Janelle the POV, they sealed their own fate.

    She nominates them next week. They are taken out of the voting. This leaves Dani, James, Erika and George to do the voting and Janelle with the power to break any tie. All Janelle has to do is sway 2 votes and one of them goes home. End of Chill Town.

    Stupid play guys.

  51. wendy Says:
    August 24th, 2006 at 5:18 pm

    I think Jani is just a B**** and I use to like this show untill Janelle got a do over and James who was injured didn’t. This is so fake I cant beleive it. I have always been a fan of the show but right is right and wrong is wrong!!!!!!

  52. chris Says:
    August 24th, 2006 at 5:22 pm

    I dont know if I will ever feel the same about the show. If Jani won fair I wouldnt care if she won. But to attack someone to win is just wrong. What if it was the other way around how would everyone feel if it was James who attacked her and went on to will POV.

  53. Tom Says:
    August 25th, 2006 at 12:23 pm

    I find it weird that in the DIG YOUR OWN GRAE comp. Janelle won, but didn’t have to suffer from anything. Dani got lockdown. Janelle just made everyone els suffer.

  54. will Says:
    September 6th, 2006 at 7:27 am

    it showed that janelle is telling the truth


SheKnows Entertainment