Of Course Scotty is the better singer…by a mile. Listen to Patrick sing ‘You dance’ and listen to Scotty.. apart from him forgeting the lyrics, just listen to the voice. Patrick was flat key all the way. Talking about looks? A lot of people think Patrick is good looking, but mind you ‘beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder, To me and I’m sure to a lot of people Scotty is cuter and he is charming, his personality is beyond comparison. the most UNIQUE voice I’ve heard in a young guy.