« | Home | »

Breaking Amish Recap: Saying Goodbye to Simple

September 10, 2012 02:00 AM by Melissa Stavarski

First comes Honey Boo Boo, then comes Breaking AmishTLC‘s newest reality series Breaking Amish follows five young men and women who leave their Amish and Mennonite communities to chase big dreams in New York City… think Real World on steroids. The premiere introduces Kate, Jeremiah, Sabrina, Abe, and Rebecca as they prepare to leave the simple life behind, the only life they’ve ever known, for an adventure in the Big Apple.

Rumspringa is a period of time that begins when an Amish child turns 16 and ends when they must choose between being baptized and leaving the community. During Rumspringa, most of their time is spent in youth groups, with a focus on courtship, and sometimes boundaries are pushed – with clothing, music, alcohol, etc. – but the youth stay close to home.

Breaking Amish is not an example of Rumspringa. These are adults who are choosing to leave their community, families, and church, and this comes with lasting (and harsh) consequences. Even if these five young women and men decide to return to the simple life at the end of the series, their family and friends will be forced to shun them.

Their lives will never be the same again….

Kate, 21

Kate is the Bishop’s daughter.  Kate says she constantly feels the need to play the part of “Bishop’s daughter,” instead of just being herself. She feels stifled.

Kate’s big dream is to be a model. She wants to ditch her plain clothes and use makeup, both of which are against Amish dress code.

Before Kate even has the chance to tell her parents she plans to go to New York City, Kate’s father catches her with the camera crew and kicks her out of the house. Homeless, Kate travels from Pennsylvania to Florida to stay with friends. While in Florida, Kate is charged with a DUI.

Kate returns to her home, to tell her parents about her DUI and New York City. When she cannot find the right words, Kate decides to send a letter instead. Kate says, “It’s a big deal to go to NYC. It’s huge.”

Jeremiah, 32

Cars fascinate Jeremiah – his big dream is to drive a car for a living. So simple, really.  He also wants to see the “huge buildings” in New York City.

Jeremiah is adopted. He’s slightly bitter about being adopted into an Amish family. He says, “Being Amish, we can’t do nothing. We do everything the hard way. First of all, I was adopted and got thrown into this Amish crap. It’s not cool.” Jeremiah fixates on the what ifs… what if he had been adopted by an English family?

Jeremiah’s girlfriend’s name is Iva. They have been dating for two years, they’re planning a fall wedding. Jeremiah asks Iva, “Do you like life around here?” Iva answers, “Yes. I have you. I don’t need more.” Iva tells Jeremiah that she’ll never be able to speak to him again, if he leaves, and she coldly walks away. Jeremiah explains that the Amish are not allowed to show their emotions. Despite Iva’s stern exterior, Jeremiah thinks she hurts inside.

When the Bishop’s wife rides by on her bike (looking like Miss Gulch from The Wizard of Oz) and spies Jeremiah with the camera crew, he packs his suitcase and bolts.

Sabrina, 25

Sabrina is the only Mennonite of the group. Sabrina shows off her giraffe teakettle, which is kind of awesome, her refrigerator, which she describes as the thing that keeps her from dying of food poisoning, and her stash of hidden magazines. Sabrina longs to be a singer. In her community, singing for an audience is considered “showing off.”

Like Jeremiah, Sabrina is adopted. Sadly, Sabrina feels as if she spent her entire life trying to live up to her adoptive father’s expectations – never quite getting there or feeling accepted. Sabrina’s story is heart wrenching. She demonstrates several nervous ticks and looks terrified constantly.

Sabrina wants to go to New York City to wear any clothes she wants to, have fun, and learn more about her Italian and Puerto Rican heritage.

Sabrina tells her parents, who refuse to be on camera, that she’s leaving. Sabrina says her mother takes the news well. However, Sabrina’s father condemns her, telling her she needs to be a better Mennonite, she’s rebelling, she’s not being a submissive woman, and she’s not being the kind of woman God intends for her to be.

Despite receiving hate mail/threats and her loved ones shunning her, Sabrina moves forward with her plan. She worries a little though. She says, “I’m going to New York City to find myself. What if I don’t? Then I have nothing.”

Abe, 22

Abe’s brother, sister, and mother appear on camera but do not have much to say… at first.

Abe’s mother warns him he’ll be shunned if he goes to New York City. Abe says, “I’m willing to risk all that to see what’s out there. I feel you should be able to do what you want, to follow your dreams.” Abe tells his family he wants to be a pilot. Abe’s mother simply says, “The Amish don’t fly.”

Abe’s brother Andy seems to be cautiously happy for Abe. When Abe asks Andy if he would visit, he says yes. About dating a good-looking girl, Andy smiles. Still, Andy fears being shunned, so he’s staying behind.

Abe feels snubbed when his family does not wish him well or offer any goodbye hugs. Again, the Amish are not allowed to show their emotions.

Abe fully expects to return to the community and marry an Amish woman… after he lives it up in New York City a little.

Rebecca, 20

Rebecca strives for equality.  ”I don’t think it’s right that a woman has to stand underneath a man. I think we should be equal,” she says.  Rebecca talks about life without car, TV, radio, and electricity.

Rebecca is nervous to tell her Grandpa, who practically raised her, that she’s going to New York City. Before she gets the chance to fully explain, Grandpa gets upset about the camera crew and tells Rebecca to pack her stuff and get out. Kicked out… just like that.

From here, TLC follows Kate, Jeremiah, Sabrina, Abe, and Rebecca as they travel by airplane for the first time, discover modern conveniences such as ATMs, and explore New York City. The previews include copious amounts of alcohol, bull rides, tattoos, sex, and bikinis… oh my!

Did you watch Breaking Amish? What did you think? 

Want more? Follow our tweets on Twitter and like us on Facebook!. Click here for more information about Reality TV. For other great reality TV news, please feel free to check out SirLinksALot: Reality TV.

Photo Credit: TLC

Topics: Breaking Amish, TLC Reality TV Shows |

« | Home | »

recommended for you


8 Responses to “Breaking Amish Recap: Saying Goodbye to Simple”

  1. BillyBob Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 4:28 am

    Anyone notice that when they first interview Jeremiah (the guy from Holmes County, OH) they show a Lancaster Couny (PA) buggy go down the road?

  2. Jen at PIWTPITT.com Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 6:22 am

    I haven’t seen this show yet, but this premise actually makes me feel more sick to my stomach than Honey Boo Boo. At least HBB has seen reality TV and has a pretty good idea of how they’ll be exploited. I didn’t think TLC could go any lower, but I guess I was wrong. These Amish kids have no idea. TLC will tempt them and cause their destruction and be there to film it, but won’t give a shit when they’re broken and need someone to fix them.

  3. maria papaluca Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 7:36 am

    we are not amish nor are we mennonites. we are christians and would welcome any or all with open arms; i would even consider letting them be part of our family. God bless them and keep them safe while they are on the journey to find themselves.

  4. myrna Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 9:33 am

    yes I agree with the comment about ” TLC won’t give a shit when they’re broken and needs someone to fix them” I would have much rather seen these kids move into mainstream homes ( maybe something like forgin exchange students do) in the same community where they struggle to become and live “normal american lives” that would be a lot more interesting than throwing them into extreamities in NYC. Of course they are going to fail and be misrable. More fun to see them evolve and become of value to our world and themselves becoming middle america like the majority of working everyday people.

  5. Melissa Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 12:18 pm

    Jen, I agree with you 100%, as always.

  6. Ashley Says:
    September 10th, 2012 at 12:33 pm

    it’s been all over the internet. (i know you shouldn’t trust anything you read from it) but jeremiah apparently hasn’t been with the amish for the past 10 yrs! he’s even divorced with kids. the whole show is a scripted scam. rebbecca and abe have a child together as well. i’m choosing to believe the rumors how did everyone just come up with this story?

  7. Jerry Says:
    September 28th, 2012 at 4:19 pm

    I feel bad for them. I dont think the Amish way of life is very easy at all. I dont know why it was such a sin for them when they left because all Amish kids get Rumspringa? They are just like us. I visit Lancaster alot. One Amish lady told me we arent much different than you. We have the same problems here. Some Amish are poor, some have psychological problems, drugs, money problems. The only thing I dontlike about them is that they are a male dominant society what the man says go. They should have more faith in their woman. I think all of these kids are going to go back to the Amish way of life.

  8. Jerry Says:
    September 28th, 2012 at 4:21 pm

    I feel the most for Rebecca. Making fun of her false teeth was downright mean. Sometimes the Amish will have their kids teeth removed to save money so they dont need dental. Now thats fuqed up!!


SheKnows Entertainment